Broncos Best Divisional Playoff Wins

It’s the NFL divisional playoffs this weekend and instead of watching the Chiefs, let’s instead review the greatest divisional playoff weekends in Broncos history. Here’s my top 5. 

5. January 14, 2006. The two-time defending NFL champion New England Patriots visit Denver to face the 13-3 AFC West champion Broncos. Champ Bailey’s 100-yard interception return late in the third quarter is a 14-point swing in favor of the Broncos, who go on to win 27-13. It was the Broncos’ first playoff win since Super Bowl XXXIII, ending a seven-year drought. However, the Broncos fell to the Steelers in the AFC Championship game a week later and fell short of Super Bowl XL. 

4. January 4, 1987. The Broncos host the defending AFC champion Patriots at Mile High. Denver clings to a 20-17 lead throughout the fourth quarter until Rulon Jones sacks Tony Eason in the end zone to clinch victory with less than two minutes remaining. This is the Broncos’ first playoff win since beating the Raiders on New Year’s Day 1978 - they had lost five playoff games in a row. The Broncos, of course, went on to beat the Browns the following week to advance to Super Bowl XXI. 

3. January 4, 1998. The Broncos go on the road to face the top-seeded Kansas City Chiefs at Arrowhead Stadium, a place that has been traditionally difficult for Denver, especially late in the season. The Chiefs overtook the Broncos for the AFC West lead late in the season, aided by a last-second field goal to beat Denver in November. In this one, the Broncos proved their superiority, with the defense holding off a late Chiefs drive to preserve a 14-10 win. It was only the second road playoff win in Broncos’ history. The Broncos won the third road playoff game in Broncos’ history the following week in Pittsburgh to advance to Super Bowl XXXII.

2. December 24, 1977. The Broncos host the Pittsburgh Steelers in the first playoff game in their 18-year franchise history. The Broncos own the AFC’s top seed thanks to their 12-2 record, but the Steelers are only two years removed from back-to-back Super Bowl titles. The two teams engage in a tight back-and-forth for three and a half quarters on Christmas Eve until Denver takes control late in the fourth. Following a turnover, Craig Morton connects with Jack Dolbin for the clinching touchdown in a 34-21 victory. Denver beats Oakland the following week to advance to Super Bowl XII.

1. January 4, 1992. The Houston Oilers visit Denver following a win in the wildcard round. Although Denver sported a better record than Houston, they had suffered a 42-14 loss in the Astrodome the previous October. Early on, this one was trending in the same direction, with the Oilers jumping to 14-0 and 21-6 leads in the first half. However, the Broncos steadily climbed back in the game and with just over two minutes remaining trailed 24-23 and had the ball at their own two-yard line. John Elway proceeded to execute “The Drive II” in which he converted two fourth downs. The second of these was a 44-yard pass to Vance Johnson to put Denver in position for the winning field goal by David Treadwell. The following week, the Broncos lost a heartbreaker to the Buffalo Bills in the AFC Championship game, falling short of Super Bowl XXVI. 

Pretty interesting that three of the five took place on January 4, and the other two games took place on dates ending with a 4. I don’t know what it means but it’s interesting. 

Rewatch: Broncos @ Steelers 9/15/86

The Broncos and Steelers on Monday Night Football, live from Pittsburgh, PA. Frank Gifford is in the booth with his new partner…Al Michaels! A young Al Michaels, just beginning a four-decade run of prime time NFL broadcasts. 

This is a fairly dull game in comparison to the Broncos’ season-opening win over the Raiders. The Broncos maintain a 7-0 lead into the third quarter. When the Steelers finally get a field goal, Michaels gleefully notes that Pittsburgh’s first points came at the 100 minute and 6 second mark of their season. They were blanked 30-0 in their opening game against the Seahawks. 

The Broncos respond with a quick 6-play, 80-yard drive, capped by John Elway faking a handoff to Sammy Winder and throwing deep to Steve Sewell for a 34-yard touchdown. 

However, the Steelers offense has awakened and they answer with their second consecutive scoring drive. Rich Erenberg scores from 7 yards out on a fourth-and-1 and it's a 14-10 ballgame with just under ten minutes left in regulation.

On the first play of the ensuing drive, the Broncos turn to another one of Danny Reeves' famous gadget plays. Elway tosses it to Gerald Willhite, who winds up and throws a strike to a wide, wide open Steve Watson for an apparent 79-yard touchdown. It's called back for an illegal forward pass, but the replays show that everything was clean. The line of scrimmage was the Denver 21 yard line, Elway threw it from about the 13, and Willhite caught it at about the 11. He took a few steps forward before releasing the ball, but was still well behind the line of scrimmage. The NFL has instituted instant replay for the 1986 season, and this seems like a great candidate for a reversal. But nothing happens.

Only after the Broncos run another play do the officials stop the action to discuss. Eventually, they decide that nothing can be done because the Broncos had already run another play. 

The Broncos wind up punting. Al Michaels lets us know that the replay booth said they hadn't been sure of what the call was on the field, and that's why no action was taken. Although it seemed pretty clear to me that the call was illegal forward pass on number 47, because that’s what the referee said when he turned on his mic.

Oh well. The Pittsburgh crowd is now fired up as the Steelers move into Denver territory, sensing the opportunity to turn the game in their favor. However, the drive ends with the Steelers’ David Hughes fumbling it away at the 35-yard line. The Broncos don't do anything with it, so the Steelers get another shot, but this time Mark Malone is intercepted by Tony Lilly, putting the Broncos in excellent field position. On the first play after the two-minute warning, Elway tosses it to Winder, who finds his way to the end zone for the clinching score.

My family acquired our first VCR at some point during the NFL offseason, and so my childhood problem of only being able to stay up until halftime of Monday night games was solved! This was the first of many games I taped through the years.

After the Broncos offense has returned to the sidelines following the final score, we hear Elway’s voice, “I want to say hi to my mom and wife” and then the camera goes to him on the sideline. He says, “Hi mom, Hi Janet, Hi Jessi. Woo!” I remember rewinding this greeting over and over again because a) I could, these VCRs are amazing b) it was hilarious and c) it was maybe the first quasi-personal interaction I had with Elway. We didn’t get Denver TV stations at the time, so we didn't get any of the extra coverage outside of the on-field action. 

Hello from Pittsburgh

Controversy would have ensued if the Steelers had taken advantage of the failed instant replay and rallied for a win. They did note that the Broncos were one of four teams to vote against instant replay, with the Steelers abstaining. Clearly the NFL didn't have the kinks worked out yet and it took years of stops and starts and tinkering to arrive at the system we have in place now. But even though we have challenge flags and automatic review of scoring plays and advanced cameras, there are still calls that get missed in the modern NFL.

History Repeats?

Today the Denver Broncos will play the Buffalo Bills in an AFC wildcard game. Why is it called wildcard when half the teams in this round won their division? Well, that question is beyond the scope of this post. The game kicks off at 11:00 AM MST in Buffalo. Where will I be for the first Broncos playoff game in nine years? At church, of course. The meeting schedule changed with the new year, and so church begins at 11:30. We’ll get home around 3:00, long after the game as concluded. So I’ll miss the live broadcast.

The last time the Broncos and the Bills met in the playoffs was January 1992, and I faced a similar scenario. It was the AFC Championship, I believe set to kick off at 10:30 AM. Our ward’s meeting schedule began at 9:00 for most of my life, but for this year it was changed to 11:00. I was in my teens at the time, and while it was disappointing to miss the live broadcast, I just set the old VCR. And then I would watch it afterwards, not knowing the result before I started. At least that was my plan.

Such a plan only works if you don’t accidentally hear something before you get home to rewind and watch the tape. In this case, someone in our ward went home during our meeting block and checked the score. And then came back in the door and loudly announced, which I overheard. So my plan to get full enjoyment of the game was spoiled!

The Broncos were not favored in this particular game. This was the peak era of Buffalo Bills football. They were the defending AFC champions, with back-to-back 13-3 seasons in the book. Jim Kelly, Thurman Thomas, Andre Reed, Bruce Smith. The Broncos were coming off the Drive II where they narrowly escaped with a win over the Houston Oilers. They were a solid team, but beating the Bills on the road would not be easy. Yet when I heard that the Bills were holding onto a narrow 7-0 lead, I was encouraged. What to do??

I had a friend named Mike, who had keys to his family’s minivan. We wound up skipping the last hour of church and went out to listen to the fourth quarter on the radio. The Broncos nearly pulled the upset. Even though John Elway was out of the game, Gary Kubiak engineered a late drive to narrow it to 10-7. And then they recovered the onside kick. Could it be another miracle win, taking its place alongside “The Drive” and “The Fumble”? Alas, no. The Broncos fumbled near midfield, and the Bills held on for a close win. I think it was years later before I went back and watched the tape.

I don’t have a way to record the game today. I’m not signing up for YouTube TV at a rate of $90 a month so I can DVR. I do have the internet to keep me posted on the results, and I guess if I want to watch later there’s the NFL plus premium subscription for $15 that could facilitate that. It’s kicking off right now and I’m not sure what I’ll do. 

I don’t expect these Broncos to win this game, but sometimes you’re pleasantly surprised. We’ll see what happens!

A Word on the 2024 Broncos

And now a break from our regularly scheduled rewatching of mid-1980s Broncos games to check in on the current edition of the team.

Tomorrow they host the 15-1 Kansas City Chiefs in the season finale. If the Broncos win, they are in as the #7 seed in the AFC playoffs and head to Buffalo next weekend for their first playoff game since Super Bowl 50. Tall order? Not especially. The Chiefs are resting most of their top guys, meaning that the Broncos will likely claim victory over KC’s junior varsity.

I would have preferred it not be this way. The Broncos clinched their first winning season since 2016 on December 15 with a comeback win over the Colts. They were 9-5 and their win streak was at four games. All they needed was one more win to clinch a playoff spot, and at that point, rising as high as the #5 seed was not out of the question. Instead, they blew a halftime lead to the Chargers on the Thursday before Christmas and then lost in overtime last week to the Bengals. This kept playoff hopes alive for the Bengals as well as the Dolphins, who will claim the #7 seed with a victory over the hopeless Jets should the Broncos falter. 

It’s hard to say this isn’t backing into the playoffs. A win over the Chiefs will count in the standings regardless of who plays or doesn’t, but it does feel a little cheap. Also, five years ago the Broncos would already have been out of luck at this point but a 17-game season and a 14-team playoff have made this possible. 

The other issue is the fact that the 2024 Broncos are a bit of a paper tiger. Their record is a sterling 7-0 against teams with losing records, but only 1-6 against teams with winning records. They’ve split their games against two 8-8 teams, the Bengals and the Falcons. The best team they’ve beaten all year is the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, who currently have the same record as the Broncos. 

However it happens, it will be good to break this ugly streak of eight seasons missing the playoffs and talking about something besides what new coach they should hire. And it’s nice to see that Bo Nix has turned out to be reasonably competent and we’re not trying to figure out how to run him out of town. We have something to build on, which is less depressing than rolling out different combinations every year and hoping it works out. They still lack serious offensive threats - i.e. Pro Bowl level talent at running back, tight end, and receiver, and one has to wonder how good their defense actually is after some of these late-season showings. 

This season has been encouraging and it’s been fun to watch games that actually seem to matter, although this team is a long ways from competing for AFC supremacy with the Ravens, Chiefs, and Bills.